• Popular
    • Medicine
    • Radiology
    • Cardiology
    • Surgery
    • Nanomedicine
    • Military Medicine
    • Rehab
  • Categories
    • Exclusive
    • A-D
      • Anesthesiology
      • Art
      • Cardiac Surgery
      • Cardiology
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diagnostics
    • E-I
      • Emergency Medicine
      • ENT
      • Genetics
      • Geriatrics
      • GI
      • Informatics
    • M-N
      • Medicine
      • Military Medicine
      • Nanomedicine
      • Net News
      • Neurology
      • Neurosurgery
      • Nuclear Medicine
    • O-P
      • Ob/Gyn
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopedic Surgery
      • Pathology
      • Pediatrics
      • Plastic Surgery
      • Psychiatry
      • Public Health
    • R-V
      • Radiation Oncology
      • Radiology
      • Rehab
      • Reproductive Medicine
      • Space Medicine
      • Sports Medicine
      • Surgery
      • Thoracic Surgery
      • Urology
      • Vascular Surgery
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Submit PR
  • About
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    • Youtube
    • Instagram
    • RSS
  • Submit PR
  • Log in
Medgadget
Medgadget
  • Popular
    • Medicine
      Antibacterial Peptide Spray Safe for Use on Wounds

      Antibacterial Peptide Spray Safe for Use on Wounds

      Flexible Sensors Detect Heavy Metals in Sweat

      Flexible Sensors Detect Heavy Metals in Sweat

      Nanopore Sensor to Study Protein Aggregation in Neurodegeneration

      Nanopore Sensor to Study Protein Aggregation in Neurodegeneration

      Biobots Use Optogenetic Muscle Actuators for Movement

      Biobots Use Optogenetic Muscle Actuators for Movement

    • Radiology
      Tiny Patch for Cardiac Ultrasound Imaging

      Tiny Patch for Cardiac Ultrasound Imaging

      Ultrasound Tornado Rapidly Disrupts Blood Clots

      Ultrasound Tornado Rapidly Disrupts Blood Clots

      Exciting Medtech at the Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

      Exciting Medtech at the Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

      Fluorescence Imaging System Illuminates Tumor Depth

      Fluorescence Imaging System Illuminates Tumor Depth

    • Cardiology
      Tiny Patch for Cardiac Ultrasound Imaging

      Tiny Patch for Cardiac Ultrasound Imaging

      Belt Monitors Heart Failure Patients

      Belt Monitors Heart Failure Patients

      Camera Measures Blood Pressure with Quick Look

      Camera Measures Blood Pressure with Quick Look

      Monitoring Congestive Heart Failure Through Speech: Interview with Tamir Tal, CEO of Cordio Medical

      Monitoring Congestive Heart Failure Through Speech: Interview with Tamir Tal, CEO of Cordio Medical

    • Surgery
      Antibacterial Peptide Spray Safe for Use on Wounds

      Antibacterial Peptide Spray Safe for Use on Wounds

      Microneedle Bandage for Hemostatic Control

      Microneedle Bandage for Hemostatic Control

      Biobots Use Optogenetic Muscle Actuators for Movement

      Biobots Use Optogenetic Muscle Actuators for Movement

      Implantable Device Adheres to Muscle, Treats Atrophy

      Implantable Device Adheres to Muscle, Treats Atrophy

    • Nanomedicine
      Extra Hot Nanoparticles for Cancer Therapy

      Extra Hot Nanoparticles for Cancer Therapy

      Making Tumors Tastier for the Immune System

      Making Tumors Tastier for the Immune System

      Improved Membrane Coating for Anti-Cancer Nanoparticles

      Improved Membrane Coating for Anti-Cancer Nanoparticles

      Magnetic Bacteria Target Tumors

      Magnetic Bacteria Target Tumors

    • Military Medicine
      Device Measures Hemoglobin More Accurately in Dark Skin

      Device Measures Hemoglobin More Accurately in Dark Skin

      Fingertip Sensor Measures Lithium Levels in Sweat

      Fingertip Sensor Measures Lithium Levels in Sweat

      Fabric Makes Electricity from Movement to Power Wearables

      Fabric Makes Electricity from Movement to Power Wearables

      Wearable Uses Microneedles to Track Metabolism

      Wearable Uses Microneedles to Track Metabolism

    • Rehab
      Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired People

      Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired People

      Implantable Device Adheres to Muscle, Treats Atrophy

      Implantable Device Adheres to Muscle, Treats Atrophy

      Non-Invasive Spinal Modulation for Cerebral Palsy

      Non-Invasive Spinal Modulation for Cerebral Palsy

      Implanted Magnets for Prosthetic Control

      Implanted Magnets for Prosthetic Control

  • Categories
    • Exclusive
    • A-D
      • Anesthesiology
      • Art
      • Cardiac Surgery
      • Cardiology
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diagnostics
    • E-I
      • Emergency Medicine
      • ENT
      • Genetics
      • Geriatrics
      • GI
      • Informatics
    • M-N
      • Medicine
      • Military Medicine
      • Nanomedicine
      • Net News
      • Neurology
      • Neurosurgery
      • Nuclear Medicine
    • O-P
      • Ob/Gyn
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopedic Surgery
      • Pathology
      • Pediatrics
      • Plastic Surgery
      • Psychiatry
      • Public Health
    • R-V
      • Radiation Oncology
      • Radiology
      • Rehab
      • Reproductive Medicine
      • Space Medicine
      • Sports Medicine
      • Surgery
      • Thoracic Surgery
      • Urology
      • Vascular Surgery
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Submit PR
  • About
  • Log in
  • Submit PR
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    • Youtube
    • Instagram
    • RSS

Feet to the Fire: Responding to Dr. Godlee

March 2nd, 2007 Medgadget Editors Exclusive

Over the last few weeks, we’ve taken BMJ editor Dr. Fiona Godlee to task for her recent piece, Reducing the Carbon Footprint of Medical Conferences. We noted the irony of Dr. Godlee urging doctors to lead by example and reduce the environmental impact of medical conferences when, in fact, she travels by air to conferences quite often. We set up an interactive map where readers can follow Dr. Godlee’s travels and report their own sightings.
And, most importantly, we asked Dr. Godlee about steps she and BMJ are planning to take, to reduce their carbon emissions: are they willing to put their footprint where their mouth is?
Well, Dr. Godlee was good enough to respond to our missive (comment #3 in this thread) — some of which is exceprted below.

… my business travel is rather more extensive than you have so far managed to document; indeed were it not so I might be charged with failing to do my job. But I’m grateful to you for taking the trouble to track my carbon footprint and for keeping me on my toes about this. If I can help with further information, please let me know. To your charge of hypocrisy I am tempted to hold my hand up and say that this is a fair cop. But on the basis of what I have written I don’t think the charge stands. In our recent editorial, Ian Roberts and I said:
1. Climate change is important
2. Air travel contributes to it
3. Much air travel is unnecessary
4. We should try to reduce it and some are already doing so.
You don’t argue with any of these substantive points. Of course I fully acknowledge the need for anyone writing about climate change to lead by personal example. Individual behaviour change is one of the four elements of the newly formed Health Climate Council’s strategy (see What can we do about climate change? BMJ 2006;333:983-984). I have a long way to go to meaningfully reduce my own contribution, but I’m working on it and doing what I can to encourage others in the same direction. Inspired by your intervention I’ll update my climate blog on bmj.com so anyone interested can judge how well or badly I’m doing. The BMJ Group is also taking seriously the need to lead on this, with increased investment in online conferencing and online learning…

(The emphasis is ours). We’re pleased with this dialogue, but it seems to some extent we’re talking past each other. From our perspective as writers for the Internet Journal of Emerging Medical Technology, our environmental impact is insignificant compared to the forests that have been consumed to deliver BMJ across the world (and you can’t beat our price). Also, we regularly feature telemedicine breakthroughs that allow for remote monitoring and diagnosis — spreading knowledge without spreading emissions from travel. Furthermore, Medgadget’s editorial team includes Soviet emigres, who too often heard speeches from the party leadership, hypocritically forcing the masses to sacrifice. When a globe-trotting editor of a pulp publication tells us we should cut down on our activities, it rubs us the wrong way.
Dr. Godlee has been writing on this issue for sixteen years. But she still cites vague Health Climate Council strategies and touts announcements about increased investments in teleconferencing. We were much more impressed with her (or her colleague’s) decision to drop out of an all-expense paid Australian presentation due to its environmental impact. We’d be more impressed if BMJ cut its members travel budget, and passed the savings directly into teleconference technology. More importantly, since deforestation’s contribution to global warming outweighs that of air travel, we’d love to hear some announcements about BMJ phasing out their costly, wasteful paper products, and joining us in the realm of web-only publications.
In her response, Dr. Godlee proceeded to ask about us — who funds us, how are our carbon footprints, and “perhaps most importantly of all given the fact that you are a technology site, what practical advice can you give publishers and others in health care about how they can most effectively transform an entrenched medical culture built on face to face meetings and global interaction?”
That’s fair, so let’s be clear: We are a group of students, researchers and physicians who subscribe to the HON code in our web-only publication. We are sponsored by advertisers displayed above the logo and along the ride side of your screen; no political groups or lobbyists are secretly funding our activities.
As far as our individual carbon footprints — half of us don’t own cars. Most of us live in small apartments, and take public transit (or walk!) to work. Some of us even have compact fluorescents in their sockets, and write from energy-star rated computers. We’re no angels, but then again, we’re not lecturing our peers on how to live.
Dr. Godlee asked us for advice in transforming an entrenched culture of medicine, based on face-to-face meetings and printed journals. Our experience is that scolding never promotes change; action and evidence do. BMJ’s actions are still their infancy. And as for evidence, why not employ technology like Access Grid, which has been available for years (Nature subscription req’d) and has demonstrated its value in a variety of settings.
Look, as far as models of weather go, non-linear phenomena are beyond the scope of our knowledge (and, probably, beyond hers as well). But we believe in the stewardship of our environment — we’ll support anyone who makes an honest and practical attempt at lowering their personal pollution output, and we’ll promote technologies that use less energy, create less interference, and create fewer tertiary effects.
What we can’t abide is doubletalk. Dr. Godlee wants to use her pulpit to advocate for change — well, good for her. But instead of scolding and urging others to sacrifice, she should use her position as head of an esteemed scienfitic journal to promote research on the wastefulness of conferences and paper journals, and steer the British Medical Journal clear of those practices. Evidence and action change behavior, not editorials.
We’d like to thank Dr. Godlee for taking the time to respond to us, and for her good-natured interpretation of our coverage. We look forward to the revival of her climate blog, and for news about BMJ’s initiatives to reduce waste and emissions.

Medgadget Editors

Medical technologies transform the world! Join us and see the progress in real time. At Medgadget, we report the latest technology news, interview leaders in the field, and file dispatches from medical events around the world since 2004.

Sponsored
C-mo Medical Solutions extends seed investment round to €4.8 million to transform cough monitoring

C-mo Medical Solutions extends seed investment round to €4.8 million to transform cough monitoring

New Clarius Power Fan HD3 Delivers a First for Handheld Ultrasound: Continuous Scanning

New Clarius Power Fan HD3 Delivers a First for Handheld Ultrasound: Continuous Scanning

Fluidx Unveils New Embolic for Neurovascular Use

Fluidx Unveils New Embolic for Neurovascular Use

Annalise.ai and Nuance Communications (a Microsoft Company) Announce Key Partnership to Improve Patient Outcomes with Workflow-Integrated AI

Annalise.ai and Nuance Communications (a Microsoft Company) Announce Key Partnership to Improve Patient Outcomes with Workflow-Integrated AI

PT Genie Unveils New Brand Identity Reflecting Company’s Transformation and Focus on the Global Future of AI and Machine Learning in Digital Healthcare

interviews & reviews
Balance Boards to Stay Active in the Offfice: Interview with Joel Heath, CEO of FluidStance 

Balance Boards to Stay Active in the Offfice: Interview with Joel Heath, CEO of FluidStance 

Exciting Medtech at the Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

Exciting Medtech at the Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

Medgadget Visits Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

Medgadget Visits Healthcareᐩ Expo Taiwan

Diabetes Management Tech for Type II patients: Interview with Jeffrey Brewer, CEO of Bigfoot Biomedical

Diabetes Management Tech for Type II patients: Interview with Jeffrey Brewer, CEO of Bigfoot Biomedical

Monitoring Congestive Heart Failure Through Speech: Interview with Tamir Tal, CEO of Cordio Medical

Monitoring Congestive Heart Failure Through Speech: Interview with Tamir Tal, CEO of Cordio Medical

In-Office Pediatric Ear Tube Procedures: Interview with Preceptis Medical's Greg Mielke

In-Office Pediatric Ear Tube Procedures: Interview with Preceptis Medical's Greg Mielke

Symani Microsurgical Robotic System: Interview with Mark Toland, CEO of Medical Microinstruments

Symani Microsurgical Robotic System: Interview with Mark Toland, CEO of Medical Microinstruments

  • Subscribe
  • Contact us
  • Submit
  • About
  • Back to top
Medgadget

Medical technologies transform the world! Join us and see the progress in real time. At Medgadget, we report the latest technology news, interview leaders in the field, and file dispatches from medical events around the world since 2004.

  • About
  • Editorial policies
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy
  • Submit press release
  • Advertise
© Medgadget, Inc. All rights reserved. | The Medical Revolution Will Be Blogged.
Please support this website by adding us to your whitelist in your ad blocker. Ads are what helps us bring you premium content! Thank you!
Posting....
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Email