• Popular
    • Medicine
    • Radiology
    • Cardiology
    • Surgery
    • Nanomedicine
    • Military Medicine
    • Rehab
  • Categories
    • Exclusive
    • A-D
      • Anesthesiology
      • Art
      • Cardiac Surgery
      • Cardiology
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diagnostics
    • E-I
      • Emergency Medicine
      • ENT
      • Genetics
      • Geriatrics
      • GI
      • Informatics
    • M-N
      • Medicine
      • Military Medicine
      • Nanomedicine
      • Net News
      • Neurology
      • Neurosurgery
      • Nuclear Medicine
    • O-P
      • Ob/Gyn
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopedic Surgery
      • Pathology
      • Pediatrics
      • Plastic Surgery
      • Psychiatry
      • Public Health
    • R-V
      • Radiation Oncology
      • Radiology
      • Rehab
      • Reproductive Medicine
      • Space Medicine
      • Sports Medicine
      • Surgery
      • Thoracic Surgery
      • Urology
      • Vascular Surgery
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Submit PR
  • About
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    • Youtube
    • Instagram
    • RSS
  • Submit PR
  • Log in
Medgadget
Medgadget
  • Popular
    • Medicine
      iLet Bionic Pancreas Cleared by FDA

      iLet Bionic Pancreas Cleared by FDA

      Urine Test for Parkinson’s Disease

      Urine Test for Parkinson’s Disease

      Investigating Bacterial Motion for New Treatment Strategies

      Investigating Bacterial Motion for New Treatment Strategies

      Smart Sutures Sense Inflammation, Deliver Drugs, Cells

      Smart Sutures Sense Inflammation, Deliver Drugs, Cells

    • Radiology
      Wearable Ultrasound for Deep Tissue Monitoring

      Wearable Ultrasound for Deep Tissue Monitoring

      Implanted Ultrasound Lets Chemo Access Brain

      Implanted Ultrasound Lets Chemo Access Brain

      Wearable Ultrasound Measures Tissue Stiffness Under Skin

      Wearable Ultrasound Measures Tissue Stiffness Under Skin

      Brain Decoder Spells Out Thoughts

      Brain Decoder Spells Out Thoughts

    • Cardiology
      Wearable Ultrasound for Deep Tissue Monitoring

      Wearable Ultrasound for Deep Tissue Monitoring

      Pencil-on-Paper Wearable Sensor

      Pencil-on-Paper Wearable Sensor

      Cell Culture Chamber Mimics Mechanical States of Disease

      Cell Culture Chamber Mimics Mechanical States of Disease

      Chest Wearable Provides Key Heart Measurements

      Chest Wearable Provides Key Heart Measurements

    • Surgery
      Device Moves Esophagus for Cardiac Ablation Procedure

      Device Moves Esophagus for Cardiac Ablation Procedure

      Smart Sutures Sense Inflammation, Deliver Drugs, Cells

      Smart Sutures Sense Inflammation, Deliver Drugs, Cells

      Automated Computer Assistant for Kidney Transplant Rejection Diagnostics: Interview with Study Authors

      Automated Computer Assistant for Kidney Transplant Rejection Diagnostics: Interview with Study Authors

      Soft Robotic Electrode Enables Minimally Invasive Placement

      Soft Robotic Electrode Enables Minimally Invasive Placement

    • Nanomedicine
      Bottlebrush Nanoparticles Deliver Immunostimulatory Drugs

      Bottlebrush Nanoparticles Deliver Immunostimulatory Drugs

      Nanoparticles Deliver mRNA Therapy to the Lungs

      Nanoparticles Deliver mRNA Therapy to the Lungs

      Nanoparticles Get Lymphatic Vessels Pumping

      Nanoparticles Get Lymphatic Vessels Pumping

      Bottlebrush Particle for Synergistic Drug Combinations

      Bottlebrush Particle for Synergistic Drug Combinations

    • Military Medicine
      Wearable Can Take Multiple Sweat Samples

      Wearable Can Take Multiple Sweat Samples

      Wound Dressing Detects Infection, Changes Color

      Wound Dressing Detects Infection, Changes Color

      Device Measures Hemoglobin More Accurately in Dark Skin

      Device Measures Hemoglobin More Accurately in Dark Skin

      Fingertip Sensor Measures Lithium Levels in Sweat

      Fingertip Sensor Measures Lithium Levels in Sweat

    • Rehab
      Temperature Feedback for Prosthetic Limbs

      Temperature Feedback for Prosthetic Limbs

      Brain Decoder Spells Out Thoughts

      Brain Decoder Spells Out Thoughts

      Knitted Glove Massages the Hand to Treat Edema

      Knitted Glove Massages the Hand to Treat Edema

      Empowering Stroke Survivors: Interview with Kirsten Carroll, CEO at Kandu Health

      Empowering Stroke Survivors: Interview with Kirsten Carroll, CEO at Kandu Health

  • Categories
    • Exclusive
    • A-D
      • Anesthesiology
      • Art
      • Cardiac Surgery
      • Cardiology
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diagnostics
    • E-I
      • Emergency Medicine
      • ENT
      • Genetics
      • Geriatrics
      • GI
      • Informatics
    • M-N
      • Medicine
      • Military Medicine
      • Nanomedicine
      • Net News
      • Neurology
      • Neurosurgery
      • Nuclear Medicine
    • O-P
      • Ob/Gyn
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopedic Surgery
      • Pathology
      • Pediatrics
      • Plastic Surgery
      • Psychiatry
      • Public Health
    • R-V
      • Radiation Oncology
      • Radiology
      • Rehab
      • Reproductive Medicine
      • Space Medicine
      • Sports Medicine
      • Surgery
      • Thoracic Surgery
      • Urology
      • Vascular Surgery
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Submit PR
  • About
  • Log in
  • Submit PR
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    • Youtube
    • Instagram
    • RSS

Medicare Spending Decreasing for Medical Devices

June 5th, 2006 Tim Odell Society

In what can only mean bad things for medical innovation, Medicare continues a trend of increasing scrutiny of novel medical technologies in an effort to cut costs. While this frustrates device giants like Johnson & Johnson, it can be particularly painful for smaller companies primarily built around just a handful of new products. Admittedly, Medicare has only a finite sum of money to spend, but if spending only goes to tried and true technologies, where will the next tried and true technologies come from? Bloomberg reports…

In the past two years, the agency has turned down requests for reimbursement for products including Johnson & Johnson’s artificial spine disk and Medtronic Inc.’s continuous glucose monitor for diabetics. It is also cutting payments for treatments it had agreed to pay for in the past, ranging from General Electric Co.’s X-ray machines to St. Jude Medical Inc.’s pacemakers.
“Should we pay for anything that any physician wants to provide to any patient?” says Steve Phurrough, director of coverage and analysis at the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services in Washington. “I think the answer to that is no.”
For small companies, such as Duderstadt, Germany-based Otto Bock, the consequences can be devastating. The company says it followed all the procedures that would have ensured approval in the past when developing its $500 cushion, which uses a material designed for the space agency to help prevent sores in wheelchair-bound patients by reducing the build-up of body heat–only to be told by Medicare that it needed to conduct prohibitively expensive research similar to drug studies before the cushion could be approved for reimbursement.
“It is a challenge to the industry, and it’s a frustration for the smaller manufacturer,” says Patrick Chelf, a vice president for the company’s U.S. operations in Minneapolis. “I’m not sure how this technology would make it to the marketplace now.”
Medicare accounted for $333 billion, about 17 percent, of all U.S. health spending in 2005, government officials say. Under pressure from Congress and President George W. Bush, Medicare officials are trying to contain spending that is otherwise forecast to more than double to $677 billion in seven years as the huge baby-boom generation reaches retirement age and a drug- reimbursement program that began this year takes effect.
Phurrough says the program is responding to a broader trend in health care by pressing companies to show that new products are superior to older treatments.
“With the advancement of the general scientific community’s knowledge base, the agency has attempted to match that, to say that we want evidence of benefit for those new technologies that people are asking us to pay for,” he says.
Medicare last year said it wouldn’t reimburse the use of J&J’s $11,500 Charite artificial spine disk. In April, the program said it intends to reject J&J’s bid for payments for its $26,100 iBot stair-climbing wheelchair, citing concerns about the 20-patient study the company used to win Food and Drug Administration approval for the device.
J&J is working to reverse Medicare’s position and will give the agency additional data, says Gregg Howard, vice president of sales and reimbursement at Johnson & Johnson’s iBot unit. Winning Medicare’s approval is key to increasing sales of the iBot. “The industry looks to Medicare as a barometer,” Howard says.
Otto Bock’s Chelf says the problem is that small companies such as his can’t afford to conduct the kind of randomized clinical trials Medicare requested for the wheelchair cushion. The demand “took our legs out from underneath us,” Chelf says.
“That would be difficult if we were Merck,” one of the largest U.S. drugmakers, Chelf says. “For a small manufacturer with a new technology, it’s impossible. It might be the right thing to do in the grand scheme of things, but it is impossible.”

Seems like that last quote might be a little off. Cutting back spending on newer devices is arguably the right thing to do in the short term (if your budget’s tight, it’s best to spend where there’s the least risk). If this trend continues, though, it will certainly slow medical innovation. One thing to consider whenever articles refer to healthcare costs (and particularly medgadget-based treatment) as “skyrocketing over the last 10 (or 15 or 20) years” is the influx of new therapies and devices for previously untreatable conditions.
More from Bloomberg.com…

Tim Odell

Tim Odell started with Medgadget in 2005 while in graduate school at the University of Southern California. He prided himself on his irreverent tone and Pseudoscience Fridays series. After graduating in 2007, he began his career as a biomedical engineer with a Bioness, a neurorehabilitation start up, then moved on to Stryker in 2011.

Sponsored

Packaging Compliance Labs (PCL) Celebrates Site Expansion in Grand Rapids, MI

Novel Approach to Assessing Lung Function Enables Improved Detection, Diagnosis and Treatment Decisions in Subject Exposed to Military Burn Pits

U.S. Patent Office Grants Additional Patent Protection For  Exoskeleton Focal-Force Angioplasty Platform

U.S. Patent Office Grants Additional Patent Protection For Exoskeleton Focal-Force Angioplasty Platform

Reliefband® State of Nausea Study Reveals More Than Three-Quarters of Americans Are Prevented from Enjoying Life As a Result of Regular Nausea

Reliefband® State of Nausea Study Reveals More Than Three-Quarters of Americans Are Prevented from Enjoying Life As a Result of Regular Nausea

New AI-Powered Voice Controls Streamline Ultrasound Imaging with All Clarius Handheld Systems

New AI-Powered Voice Controls Streamline Ultrasound Imaging with All Clarius Handheld Systems

interviews & reviews
Automated Computer Assistant for Kidney Transplant Rejection Diagnostics: Interview with Study Authors

Automated Computer Assistant for Kidney Transplant Rejection Diagnostics: Interview with Study Authors

RF Technology for Health Monitoring: Michael Leabman, CTO of Movano Health

RF Technology for Health Monitoring: Michael Leabman, CTO of Movano Health

AI’s role in Healthcare: Exclusive Interview with Catherine Estrampes, President & CEO at GE Healthcare

AI’s role in Healthcare: Exclusive Interview with Catherine Estrampes, President & CEO at GE Healthcare

Digital Self-Neuromodulation Therapy for PTSD: Interview with Oded Kraft, CEO of GrayMatters Health

Digital Self-Neuromodulation Therapy for PTSD: Interview with Oded Kraft, CEO of GrayMatters Health

Levels Is Making Metabolism and Blood Glucose Tracking Accessible To Everyone

Levels Is Making Metabolism and Blood Glucose Tracking Accessible To Everyone

Imagene Profiles Cancer Biomarkers in Real Time

Imagene Profiles Cancer Biomarkers in Real Time

Empowering Stroke Survivors: Interview with Kirsten Carroll, CEO at Kandu Health

Empowering Stroke Survivors: Interview with Kirsten Carroll, CEO at Kandu Health

  • Subscribe
  • Contact us
  • Submit
  • About
  • Back to top
Medgadget

Medical technologies transform the world! Join us and see the progress in real time. At Medgadget, we report the latest technology news, interview leaders in the field, and file dispatches from medical events around the world since 2004.

  • About
  • Editorial policies
  • Contact
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy
  • Submit press release
  • Advertise
© Medgadget, Inc. All rights reserved. | The Medical Revolution Will Be Blogged.
Please support this website by adding us to your whitelist in your ad blocker. Ads are what helps us bring you premium content! Thank you!
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Email