Tuesday, April 10, 2007

A Diabetic Asks: Why Don't Pumps Look Like iPods?

Filed under: Medicine , Society

warning: both devices can trigger seizures if not properly calibrated

Longtime tipster (and new author) Amy Tenderich has written an open letter to Steve Jobs of Apple, asking him to apply some of that iPod design magic to another kind of portable electronic device -- a diabetic blood sugar pump:

If insulin pumps or continuous monitors had the form of an iPod Nano, people wouldn't have to wonder why we wear our "pagers" to our own weddings, or puzzle over that strange bulge under our clothes. If these devices wouldn't start suddenly and incessantly beeping, strangers wouldn't lecture us to turn off our "cell phones" at the movie theater.

In short, medical device manufacturers are stuck in a bygone era; they continue to design these products in an engineering-driven, physician-centered bubble. They have not yet grasped the concept that medical devices are also life devices, and therefore need to feel good and look good for the patients using them 24/7, in addition to keeping us alive.

There's robust commentary at DiabetesMine. Our take? This kind of request is inevitable -- indeed, it echoes our earlier claim that the GlucoBand was the'iPod of glucose monitors.' And while the market for diabetic technology is growing, their gizmos face the common reality of all health care products -- insurers won't reimburse frills, concepts like 'cost' and 'consumer preference' are difficult to pin down in medicine, and one unfortunate reality of human nature: most people obsess and spend on things they want, rather than things they need.

More from TechCrunch...

email this article to a friend      print this!           comments and peer reviews (2)






replies: 2 comments
Open comments are not moderated, although abusive and vulgar remarks may be deleted. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of Medgadget.com. Please consult our disclaimer.

Take a look at the OmniPod system


Posted by: John
on April 12, 2007 05:59 AM GMT

The problem with many of the current diabetes related devices is that they only consider the reliability and basic functionality for those systems.

Where the manufacturers really need to copy the iPod approach is in realizing that it's not just about the hardware. It's the whole infrastructure around the system, that includes both software and hardware.

Of the three diabetes devices that I use, none have software that helps me to use the data collected in a meaningful way. None of the devices have a common connection cable, or data format. And they have no exportable data formats in common.

One example from the three. The new Dexcom continuous glucose monitor system. My post describes the challenges I'm having in getting any of the data off the device. The software that Dexcom provides only draws two pretty (but uninformative) graphs.

When will the makers of these devices realize that some of us want something that helps us in the short term (managing glucose levels, staving off hypoglycemia, etc.) and in the long term? For the latter case we need to be able to get at our data and use it for analysis and fine tuning.


Posted by: Bernard Farrell
on April 27, 2007 06:33 PM GMT

add a comment
html tags: <b>, <i>, and <a>
examples: <b>Bold</b> <i>Italic</i>









Remember personal info?
(anonymous comments allowed)



click to make your selection boldclick to make your selection italicclick to add a link


Verification (needed to reduce spam):




Click the "Post" button only once!